Transportation solutions today are filled with implications around sustainability. With the repercussions of climate change so evident in the news that people consume daily, they’re more aware than ever how every day choices impact the world around them.
ROOT provides our users with a tool that supports their sustainably-driven lifestyles while offering one centralized location for information on sustainable transportation and incorporating a more holistic view of sustainability based on our users’ needs.
CHALLENGE
Out initial challenge was to look to solutions within the transportation space. My team created a mind map delving into the many and varied areas around transportation. After coming to a consensus we settled on the area of sustainable transportation and what that means to environmentally minded users.
Through this process we realized one very important fact. Even when asking our screened user interviews those who were most concerned about their environmental impact as it pertained to transportation viewed the problem space as a more holistic issue. Across all areas of their lives from their own personal choices, feeling supported by both individuals in the community and the wider efforts by their cities their concerns far surpassed choosing between walking and driving.
Role: UX Designer
Timeline: 2 Weeks
Platform: Responsive Desktop to Mobile Breakpoints
Team: Claudia Zacharias, Toni Brown, Erica Cleary, Kendall Kessler
Figma
APPROACH
Defining Problem Space
Screener Survey
User Interviews
Affinity Mapping
Persona
Journey Map
Feature Prioritization
MVP
Wireframes & Testing
Mockups & Testing
PROCESS OVERVIEW
HYPOTHESIS
Our team hypothesized that users are frustrated by the lack of sustainable transportation options that are efficient, reliable, and take them to destinations outside of a city center.
ASSUMPTIONS
Users are frustrated by the lack of sustainable travel options
Users want to adopt more sustainable practices into their travel habits
Users want simple solutions to help incorporate more sustainable habits into their lives
Users are not always clear how to travel as sustainably as possible
ROOT Mock Up iOS Screen
THE RESEARCH
USER INTERVIEWS
To suss out if our hypothesis was accurate, and if our team was heading in a viable and valuable direction, we focused on finding the right users. Our method of finding the right users involved sending out a screener survey, particularly to those interested in sustainability practices, and currently engaged in those activities in their daily lives. After screening fourteen prospective subjects we discovered eleven were very interested in sustainable transportation and of those five were open to being interviewed by our team.
Our target demographic turned out to be adults under age forty, all of whom had a common, shared interest in educating themselves on sustainable green practices.
DATA SYNTHESIS
We learned a lot from our users and affinity mapping (mapping common themes found in the interviews) into categories was a big task. Our users had a lot to say!
These are the most common themes identified through user interviews and data synthesis:
systemic change is more important than individual changes in sustainable advancements
prefer to patron businesses that align with their values
want to live more sustainably in the future and currently actively participate in many behaviors to live more sustainably today
infrastructure barriers to access existing public transportation including
like when their cities invest in sustainable transportation infrastructure
associate sustainable living with values of honor, ethical base and admirable and feel that those who don’t lack compassion
take time to research sustainable alternatives for products they want or need
want easy access to sustainable information and initiatives that promote policy change and an eco-friendly lifestyle
KEY INSIGHTS
Breaking our many distilled insights down further into more manageable overarching themes we landed on these three key takeaways:
Infrastructure
Users want improvements to existing infrastructure
Purchasing
Users consider sustainability when making purchase and other decisions
Research
Users take the time to research sustainable solutions and companies but can find it tiring
Persona
Understanding these user pain points led the team to develop Molly. Molly is our primary user and her characteristics are representative of the most common traits, goals, needs and frustrations discovered in our interviews.
Molly’s Goals
Reduce her carbon footprint
Live sustainably
Shop at businesses that actively supporting sustainable practices
Molly’s Needs
Easy access to information on green initiatives in her city
To feel part of a community supporting shared sustainability goals
Molly’s Frustrations
Only systemic change will stop climate deterioration
She hates researching green companies but feels it’s her responsibility
She thinks the existing infrastructure needs a lot of work
How Might We…
provide Molly with sustainable solutions to and give her confidence that she is making the right choices to support an environmentally conscious lifestyle?
THE DESIGN
FEATURE PRIORITIZATION
One major insight that informed the development of our features was the overarching theme that our users don’t see sustainable transportation as a singular, isolated consideration…users don’t see sustainable behaviors as separated by categories.
Research showed that our core demographic takes a holistic view across multiple channels and experiences…not just transportation.
In our effort to prioritize potential product features we employed two methods to distill the core of what our user needs including the MoSCow method and a Feature Prioritization Matrix.
These tools helped us focus on the essentials while we benched “nice to have” options for future iterations and determined some features, deemed essential, would ultimately be too complex and costly to implement. All other essentials were incorporated into our MVP (minimum viable product).
MINIMUM VIABLE PRODUCT (MVP)
Planning a Sustainable Route
Information on Climate Impact by Transportation Type
Local Transportation Policies and Initiatives
Community Initiatives
FEATURES:
Search + Sort Options for results and filtering sustainable transportation options
A policies + initiatives page so users can access information about local community and government policies
A carbon emissions comparison page to address users frustration over navigating multiple sites and
Social media integration so users can feel connected as a community
From this point we created mid fidelity prototype to test our features with users and see if the features we created and the layout was navigable, learnable and clear. We created three scenarios and tasks around our MPV to test successes, failures and unclear paths for our users. Ultimately these test clarified some areas for improvement based on test results and general feedback provided by the first testing group.
MEDIUM FIDELITY & TESTING
We conducted a design workshop to ideate our MVP as a team, ultimately leading us to our digital mockups and the first iteration of our product. Once these were complete we created three tasks designed to assess the success of users’ ability to engage in the key features we created around:
• Planning a sustainable route
• Information on climate impact by transportation type
• Local transportation policies and initiative news and
• Updates and finally community space and initiatives
Insights around unclear and duplicative language, unnecessary navigation and more informed the design for our high fidelity prototype. More specifically, we learned that using the word “Green” twice on buttons caused confusion with users, so we changed wording for our next round of design.
The zip code section on the home screen was also confusing to users, so we removed this. These results of our testing helped us identify specific features that needed some re-thinking for our hi-fi prototype.
In keeping with the CRUD model (create, read, update, delete) we added new features to the hi-fi prototype including the option for users to create, login, edit and delete an account.
Then we moved on to round two testing of the high fidelity mockup with a new set of users employing the original scenarios and related tasks with the new group.
MOCKUPS & TESTING
Mockups made significant improvements in:
success rate | time on task | easiness rating
Task three, around discovering the sustainability of transportation by type, was the only task we did not see an improvement on, so this is something to be addressed in future iterations.
CONCLUSION
FINAL DESIGN
After creating our responsive website for mobile and desktop, our next steps would be to recruit five participants to run a usability test on our desktop site using the same three task scenarios from our mobile tests
We’d test for time on task, direct success rate, and ease of use. From that point we’d collect user feedback and redesign until it fits the users needs and address any pain points encountered during user testing.
NEXT STEPS
Our team took a mobile first design approach and ran user testing only on the mobile prototype. Next steps would be to complete those same scenarios and tasks with users on the desktop version to make sure that the adaptive layout makes sense in both layouts.
We also had the opportunity to work with a team of developers and we watched them transform our prototype into a live desktop to mobile experience which was very rewarding. Talking to their team and learning about their needs, what worked and what didn’t in the handoff was immensely valuable. Mostly the handoff went well the only mild hiccup was that their team was designing desktop first so for our timeline our team expended most of our energy on the mobile version. It was a valuable partnership to be a part of.
This step allowed us to think beyond the design stage and focus on the larger team working on this project.
Making sure that our high fidelity mock-ups were as accurate as possible was important to ensure that our group was empathetic to the needs of the engineers and developers who are taking up the baton in this project.
The more we can help them by providing a complete, clear and comprehensive file the better for the entire team and ultimately the user.